- The definition of ecotourism
Martha Honey defines ecotourism as: “...ecotourism is travel to pristine, and usually protected areas that strives to be low impact and (often) small scale. It helps educate the traveller, provides funds for conservation, directly benefits the economic development and political empowerment of local communities, and and fosters respect for different cultures and for human rights” (Honey 33). This definition brought to light the fact that ecotourism involves much more than just travel to areas of ecological interest. Before reading this definition, I did not associate ecotourism with benefitting local people, when this is arguably the most important aspect of ecotourism. This definition served as a guide for evaluating every ecotourism destination, and helped guide us in our own research projects.
Infographic depicting some core values of ecotourism |
- The differences between ecotourism, ecotourism lite and turnstile tourism
Ecotourism fits Martha Honey’s definition, as well as truly embodies each part of the definition throughout the trip. It is important to recognize that just because an organization states that a trip or experience is ecotourism does not mean that it is. Ecotourism lite is closer to turnstile tourism, but with an environmental or socially conscious twist. “When poorly planned, unregulated, and overhyped, ecotourism lite, like mass tourism or even traditional nature tourism can bring only marginal financial benefits but serious environmental or social consequences” (Honey 69). However, the experience is not truly ecotourism, and only has the exterior appearance of following one or more of Honey’s guidelines. Turnstile tourism is a classic trip to Disney World, a stint on a cruise ship, or a stay on Atlantis. This kind of tourism does not benefit host countries, and is oftentimes very socially and environmentally damaging.
Cruise Ship leaving behind waste and pollution |
- The negative impact that tourism has on indigenous communities
There have been many examples throughout our studies on indigenous communities being negatively impacted by tourism. For example, the Maasai people of Tanzania. “From the outset, conservation organizations in Europe and the United States weighed in to build an increasingly powerful lobby to expel the Maasai, arguing that the Serengeti was too fragile and its water too scarce to support both humans and wildlife” (Honey 220). Since tourism first began, Westerners have been taking advantage of indigenous peoples in the name of tourism and in the interest of generating revenue. Although ecotourism is being practiced now more than ever, this still remains an issue. Oftentimes, there is a “get on board or get out” mindset that gives local people no choice but to participate in tourism or forfeit their land.
Maasai Women, Tanzania |
- If done correctly, implementing ecotourism opportunities in developing nations can positively impact the economy.
True ecotourism benefits the host country in many ways. One of the most important ways for tourism to impact a community is economically. When chain hotels and restaurants are brought to countries in the name of tourism, money from these vacation hot spots flows out of the host country, and back to large corporations in the West. In order for ecotourism to truly be at play, the majority of profits must go to the host country. This was seen in the development of tourism in Iceland. When tourists began to flock to Iceland in pursuit of experiencing the natural beauty, it impacted the economy in a positive way. “In this same half decade period, there was a complete restructuring of the economy. Tourism surpassed fishing (previously one of the country’s largest industries), and quickly became the predominant form of economic activity” (Santos).
Iceland through an ice lens |
- Voluntourism as an alternative to turnstile tourism- if done correctly
Voluntourism, if done right, can be a great way to travel while meeting the standards of ecotourism. When volunteering abroad, it is important that those doing the volunteering do not assume that what they are doing is inherently helpful because they have good intentions. It is always important to evaluate the impact of the trip throughout the volunteering experience and ensure that the community is truly and need, and truly wants the services being offered by volunteers. In her project about voluntourism in India, Holly discussed how voluntourism aligns with the standards of ecotourism. “Voluntourism, volunteering while traveling as a tourist, turned out to be a great case of ecotourism, and one that makes me want to look into more ecotourism-resulting voluntourism in the future. According to The International Ecotourism Society’s (TIES) page on voluntourism, “You don't need to be affluent, or be able to afford months of free time, to be part of something meaningful and rewarding that helps empower local people, support communities, and enhance skills, capacity and knowledge through travel” (“Voluntourism”)” (Francis).
Chinnar Wildlife Sanctuary, India |
- Sometimes the best way to protect a fragile place is to stay home.
In the case of many remote locations of ecological interest, such as the Galapagos, tourism can be very detrimental. “To date, biodiversity in the Galapagos has survived well, but the long-term future of the biodiversity of the islands may well depend on decisions about sustainable development that are made during the next few years” (Honey 125). This goes for many places around the globe that have been environmentally and socially degraded by even the most well-intentioned tourists. It is important as an ecotourist to recognize the risk of traveling to remote locations, and to know the limits of ecotourism, even if that means not visiting a place of interest. Some ecosystems or societies are simply too fragile to handle influxes of tourists, even if those tourists are practicing ecotourism.
Turtle, Galapagos |
- As a tourist, it can be difficult to tell when travel is really ecotourism rather than ecotourism lite.
It is often difficult to decipher whether or not a tourism opportunity is actually ecotourism or is just being branded that way to draw in more revenue. This is especially prevalent on cruise ships, where cruise lines often have awards claiming “environmental stewardship” while not at all practicing those ideals.“ Currently luxury liners can dump sewage once they are three miles offshore, and can release other wastewater almost anywhere except in Alaskan waters. Ships carrying upwards of three thousand passengers and crew each produce about thirty thousand gallons of raw sewage a day-as much as a small city” (Honey 50). Some of these ecotourism “certifications” are focused only on profit, and not for bringing recognition to small businesses actually carrying out ecotourism. Ecotourism lite can draw in members of the public who are not well-versed on ecotourism, and create a false idea of what it means to travel sustainably.
Cruise ship cartoon |
- It is always important to not just plan an ecotourism trip, but to reevaluate every step of the way on the trip to make sure that the trip is truly benefiting the community.
Booking a trip with a company that claims to be dedicated to ecotourism, even if extensive research has been done is just one step of truly carrying out ecotourism, does not always guarantee an ecotourism experience. It is important for a traveller to have autonomy in evaluating ecotourism experiences, as this is the only way to ensure ecotourism is being carried out. Being a conscious traveller is always important, as it ensures that even if something goes wrong and the trip is not ecotourism, then that traveller will have the knowledge and resources to turn things around and reassess the situation. Education is one of the most important aspects of ecotourism, and should be begun long before the trip does. “It will take much stronger grass-roots movements, combines with alliances among activists, experts, and NGOs and carefully planned and implemented national ecotourism strategies, to curb the power of the conventional tourism industry” (Honey 447). This quote demonstrates how strong of a hold the conventional tourism industry has on the tourism market, and therefore, how important it is for travellers to do their own research and never blindly trust any organization.
Tourists in Alaska |
- Biodomes are a way to create an ecotourism experience in an urban landscape, and bring nature to areas where it may not be available.
Biodomes are a way to bring places of ecological interest to places where ecotourism could be possible in every other part of the definition, but may be lacking in the aspect of nature. Biodomes are centers of environmental education that instill an interest in nature and ecology to visitors. However, it is important to ensure that the trip as a whole follows the criteria of ecotourism. This is something I discussed in my research project: “Overall, it is important to analyze the five criteria for ecotourism in order to understand what makes biodomes such a unique aspect of tourism. In order for a trip to a biodome to be considered a true ecotourism experience, one must go beyond the dome and ensure that they are making a positive impact on the surrounding communities and environment by being conscious about lodging, dining, shopping, and travel methods”. Although there are concerns and criticisms surrounding animal welfare in biodomes, since biodomes are relatively new, there is research being done globally about the best way to sustain life within the domes.
Biodome in Montreal |
- Ecotourism has a long way to go, but is an up and coming way of travel that has a lot of potential to change the way we travel.
Although ecotourism is still a relatively new development in travel, it is becoming increasingly popular, and has the potential to replace turnstile tourism for many travellers. Ecotourism is not only more sustainable, but more fulfilling than turnstile tourism, and offers more life experiences that could not be found in traditional travel. “Well-run ecotourism is the only option, the only foreign exchange-earning activity that, if done with care and controls, does not lead to irreparable damage to the environment. In other instances, ecotourism is clearly more profitable than the alternative economic activities” (Honey 444). As people become more educated on the environmental and social impacts of tourism, more and more travellers are seeking alternatives. This leads those travellers to ecotourism, and creates the potential for a new take on traveling, and an increase in ecotourists around the globe.
Hanging Bridge, Costa Rica Works Cited Honey, Martha. Ecotourism and Sustainable Development: Who Owns Paradise? Island Press, 2008. |